Valentine's Day Collection
Holiday Shop Sale!
Our Favorite Brands
Wedding Invitation Suites
Wedding Event Invitations
Day of Essentials
Print at Home
Designer Wedding Invitations
In-Store Only Designers
Print At Home
Individual Seasonal Cards
Custom Cards Sale!
Designer Custom Cards Sale!
Print at Home
Thank You Notes
Gifts By Category
Gifts By Recipient
Gifts By Price
Bags & Boxes
Themed Party Supplies
Paper Source will accept returns for merchandise in its original packaging, condition, and accompanied by the original order number within the time frames provided below.
Sale merchandise and flat paper sheets, including fine paper and 26x19 or larger solid paper, are not returnable. Shipping charges are non-refundable.
Custom print orders are considered final sale after 10 days of receipt.
If for any reason, you are unhappy with your order, we kindly ask that you please contact our Customer Care team within 10 calendar days of your product being delivered. After this review period, all custom print sales are considered final.
Return items within 30 days for a full refund. We will process your return promptly upon receipt. Refund will be credited back to the original method of payment, gift card or check send. Please note: It may take one to two billing periods before refunds appear on your credit card statement.
Returns made within 31-90 days of the original purchase will be refunded to a Paper Source Gift Card at the original price paid.
No returns accepted after 90 days of original purchase.
If an item you purchased is now on sale or promotion, we will make a one-time price adjustment on full-price purchases within 14 days of original purchase. Please call 1-888-PAPER-11 (1-888-727-3711) for ecommerce and custom print price adjustment requests that fall within these guidelines; these requests can not be processed in store.
With stores across the country, it is easy to return merchandise at any Paper Source store. Just bring in your packing slip and we will take it from there.
See store locations for the store nearest you.
Repackage the items you are returning and include your packing slip with the items you are returning circled. Use your own trackable and insured shipping method* and mail to:
Paper Source 7801 Industrial Drive Forest Park, IL 60130 Attn: Web Returns
*Paper Source is not responsible for customer returns that are not received.
If you have any additional questions, please contact us at firstname.lastname@example.org or 1-888-PAPER-11 (1-888-727-3711).